Statutory demand lawyer Brisbane: what to do in 21 days
Has your Brisbane company received a statutory demand? The company has 21 days from service to pay, secure or compound the debt to the creditor's reasonable satisfaction. It can also apply to the court to set the demand aside within those 21 days. The Act gives the court no power to extend the time for that application.
Macmillan Lawyers and Advisors advises Brisbane directors from its Brisbane CBD office and by phone and video.
Call (07) 3518 8030, email admin@macmillan.law or use the enquiry form for a free 30-minute consultation.
What should you do if your company receives a statutory demand?
Start by checking the service date, then decide how the company will respond.
- Establish the date of service. The 21 days run from service of the demand on the company. Keep the demand and any accompanying documents together for advice about the deadline.
- Check the demand. Read the debt and amount claimed. Identify any dispute about the debt or any claim the company has against the creditor.
- Decide the response. Consider payment, securing or compounding the debt to the creditor's reasonable satisfaction, or an application to set it aside. The grounds for an application are explained below.
- Get advice before the 21 days end. ASIC recommends early accounting or legal advice if you suspect financial difficulty. Tell the adviser when the demand was served. Ask about both the company's response and your duties as a director.
- File and serve in time if applying. Within the 21 days, the company must make its application and file a supporting affidavit. Copies of both must also be served on the person who served the demand.
How do you set aside a statutory demand?
The company applies to the court under section 459G of the Corporations Act 2001. The court decides whether to set the demand aside.
The application, supporting affidavit and service all have to meet the 21-day limit. Filing the supporting affidavit and serving copies of both documents within that period are requirements of section 459G.
Genuine dispute or offsetting claim
Section 459H covers a genuine dispute about the existence or amount of the debt. It also covers an offsetting claim against the person who served the demand. This means a genuine counterclaim, set-off or cross-demand. The claim can arise from a different transaction or set of circumstances.
The court considers the substantiated amount under section 459H. If it is below $4,000, the court must set the demand aside. If it is at least $4,000, the court may vary the demand and declare it effective as varied from service.
Defect causing substantial injustice or some other reason
Under section 459J, the court may set a demand aside because a defect would cause substantial injustice unless it did so. A defect alone is insufficient. The court may also set it aside for some other reason.
While an order setting the demand aside is in force, the demand has no effect. The court may attach conditions to the order. If it makes no order under section 459H or 459J, it must dismiss the application. Where it sets the demand aside, it may order the person who served it to pay the company's application costs.
Can a company negotiate after receiving a statutory demand?
Yes. The Act allows the company to pay, secure or compound the debt to the creditor's reasonable satisfaction. Any proposed response should address that requirement.
For ATO demands, the ATO describes the requirement as paying the entire debt or entering a payment plan within 21 days. If you cannot pay, the ATO says to contact it or a registered tax professional immediately. It says it will work with a taxpayer who cannot pay to understand their situation.
Do not assume negotiations put the demand on hold. The Act changes the compliance period only in the circumstances it provides.
Where an application complies with section 459G, the compliance period runs until 7 days after it is finally determined or otherwise disposed of, unless the court orders an extension. That concerns compliance with the demand. The time for making the set-aside application remains fixed.
What happens if the company does nothing?
The company is taken to have failed to comply if the compliance period ends with the demand still effective and unmet. A creditor may then rely on that failure in a winding-up application.
If the failure occurred during or after the 3 months ending on the application date, the court must presume insolvency for that application. The company can rebut the presumption by proving it is solvent. The court may order an insolvent company to be wound up.
The company's ability to oppose the winding-up application is also restricted. Without the court's permission, it cannot rely on grounds it used, or could have used, to seek to set the demand aside. Permission requires the court to be satisfied that the ground is material to proving solvency.
Liquidation can transfer control to a liquidator, who sells company assets and distributes funds to creditors. For advice about this process, see liquidation lawyer Brisbane.
What is the directors' own exposure?
Directors can face insolvent trading penalties where they fail to prevent debts in the circumstances covered by section 588G. A safe harbour under section 588GA may apply, subject to its conditions.
ASIC advises directors to seek accounting or legal advice as early as possible if they suspect financial difficulty. ASIC describes a company as insolvent when it cannot pay its debts when they fall due. It says an insolvent company should incur no further debt.
Macmillan Lawyers and Advisors advises on these issues through its insolvency lawyers in Brisbane. For advice about alternatives to liquidation, see small business restructuring and voluntary administration.
Macmillan Lawyers and Advisors also advises creditors. For how a demand is made and what it must contain, read the guide to the creditor's statutory demand.
Statutory demand FAQs
FREE 30 MINUTE CONSULTATION
(speak with a Macmillan lawyer)
Speak to a Macmillan lawyer about a statutory demand
Call (07) 3518 8030, email admin@macmillan.law or use the enquiry form for a free 30-minute consultation. Macmillan Lawyers and Advisors is at Level 38, 71 Eagle Street, Brisbane City QLD 4000.
Contact us today.
We are here to help.
Level 38,
71 Eagle Street,
Brisbane QLD 4000
Join us for a free consultation.
Fill out the form below, upload any relevant documents and enter your preferred time for us to contact you.
